| Platinum | Parker John's BBQ & Pizza - Menasha |
| Gold | Cozzy Corner |
| Silver | Four Schmidt's & Giggles |
| Bronze | Hawg Tyed BBQ |
| Top Pick | Chili's Grill & Bar |
| Top Pick | Cinder's Charcoal Grill |
| Top Pick | Famous Dave's |
| Top Pick | Peters' Boyz BBQ |
| Top Pick | Tom's Drive-In |
| Top Pick | TTZ's BBQ - Menasha |