| Platinum | Mary's Family Restaurant |
| Platinum | The Wandering Table |
| Gold | Panera Bread |
| Gold | Snaps Wraps |
| Silver | Chicago's House of Hoagie's |
| Bronze | Chicagos House of Hoagies |
| Top Pick | Fome |
| Top Pick | Mark's East Side |
| Top Pick | Michiels of Menasha |
| Top Pick | Pho Saigon |