| Platinum | Bergstrom Appleton Used Car And Body Shop |
| Gold | Bergstrom Automotive |
| Silver | Gustman Honda |
| Bronze | Pete's Auto Repair |
| Top Pick | A to Z Auto Sales |
| Top Pick | Above and Beyond Auto |
| Top Pick | Ambrosius Auto |
| Top Pick | Kolosso Toyota |
| Top Pick | Les Stumpf Ford |
| Top Pick | Renew Auto Sales |