| Platinum | Kesslers Diamonds |
| Gold | J Anthony Jewelers |
| Silver | Avenue Jewelers |
| Silver | Expert Jewelry Repair |
| Bronze | Weld & Arrow |
| Top Pick | Alyssa and Anna Fine Jewelry |
| Top Pick | Fox Valley Jewelers |
| Top Pick | Tailored Hide Custom Leather & Repair |
| Top Pick | Tennies Jewerly |
| Top Pick | Uptown Links Permanent Jewelry |