| Platinum | Timeless Vintage and Consignment |
| Gold | Neenah Vintage Mall |
| Silver | Look Back in Time |
| Bronze | Ye Old Goat |
| Top Pick | Antique Up |
| Top Pick | Aurora's Apothecary |
| Top Pick | Forty Three Skulls |
| Top Pick | Memories Antique Mall |
| Top Pick | The Missing Piece Estates |
| Top Pick | Water Street Vintage |