| Platinum | Neenah Main Auto body |
| Gold | Ken's Auto Body Of Wi |
| Silver | Van Handel Autobody |
| Bronze | Pete's Auto Repair |
| Top Pick | Appleshine Autobody |
| Top Pick | Blankenship's Auto Body & Vinyl Wraps |
| Top Pick | Caliber Collision |
| Top Pick | Goss Autobody |
| Top Pick | Tim's Body Shop |
| Top Pick | Van Zeeland Collision and Paint |