| Platinum | Lubeplus |
| Gold | Autotrust |
| Gold | Pete's Auto Repair |
| Silver | Auto Select Neenah |
| Bronze | Baumgart Tire & Wheel |
| Top Pick | KBautosports, LLC |
| Top Pick | Klug Family Repair LLC |
| Top Pick | Neenah Main Auto body |
| Top Pick | Stoiched Automotive |
| Top Pick | Your Mechanic Shop |