| Platinum | Simon's Specialty Cheese |
| Gold | Union Star Cheese Factory |
| Silver | Lamers Dairy |
| Bronze | Arthur Bay Cheese Co. |
| Top Pick | Belgioioso Cheese |
| Top Pick | Haen Meat Packing, |
| Top Pick | Saputo Cheese USA |
| Top Pick | Scray Cheese |
| Top Pick | The Cheese Table, Neenah |
| Top Pick | Two Guernsey Girls Creamery |