| Platinum | Appleton Asian Market |
| Gold | Woodman's Food Market |
| Silver | Aldi |
| Silver | Niemuth's Southside Market |
| Bronze | Festival Grocery Store |
| Top Pick | Jacobs Market |
| Top Pick | Meijer |
| Top Pick | Pick 'n Save |
| Top Pick | Produce With Purpose Farm |
| Top Pick | Urban Market Neenah |