| Platinum | Carmella's An Italian Bistro |
| Gold | Luigis Pizza of Appleton |
| Silver | Victorias Italian Crusine |
| Bronze | Cannova's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Cranky Pat's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Field & Fire |
| Top Pick | Glass Nickel Pizza Co |
| Top Pick | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Pullmans At Trolley Square |
| Top Pick | Stuc's Pizza |