| Platinum | Happy Bellies Bake Shop |
| Gold | Chicago's House Of Hoagie's |
| Silver | Tria Frog Treats |
| Bronze | Funky Franks |
| Top Pick | All Things Jerky |
| Top Pick | Cereal Boxx Drilled Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Doughlicious |
| Top Pick | The Main Celebration |
| Top Pick | Urban Market Neenah |
| Top Pick | Urban Modern Kitchen |