| Platinum | LCC Thrift Store & Event Rentals |
| Gold | Community Benefit Tree |
| Silver | Fair Market Thrift Store |
| Bronze | AbleLight Thrift Shop |
| Top Pick | Bargain Garden |
| Top Pick | Chic to Chic |
| Top Pick | Neenah Vintage Mall |
| Top Pick | Rustic Resque |
| Top Pick | St Vincent DePaul Store |
| Top Pick | Timeless Vintage and Consignment |