| Platinum | Soar |
| Gold | Our Pack Animal Rescue |
| Silver | Pillars Adult & Family Shelter |
| Bronze | Unseen Abilities LLC |
| Top Pick | Community Benefit Tree |
| Top Pick | Cots Appleton |
| Top Pick | Diverse and Resilient |
| Top Pick | Down Syndrome Association of Wisconsin - Fox Cities |
| Top Pick | Harbor House |
| Top Pick | Welcoming Willows |